A Raven and A Writing Desk

Writing for Children Blog | craft | writing for children and teens | writing for magazines | Writing nonfiction for children
January 18, 2018


"How is a raven like a writing desk?"

When Lewis Carroll first wrote the riddle about the raven and the writing desk, he didn't have an answer. It was simply a riddle to stump a little girl, something nonsensical as might come up in a dream. But over time people have pondered it like a real riddle. "How is a raven like a writing desk?"

Over time, even Lewis came up with an answer: "Because it can produce a few notes, though they are very flat, and it is never put with the wrong end in front!" Though an interesting answer, it has not been enough for riddle lovers. Others have come up with still more answers.  "They both have quills dipped in ink." "Poe wrote on both." "Neither is ever approached without caws." "A writing desk is a rest for pens and a raven is a pest for wrens." Or Aldous Huxley's wonderfully nonsensical answer: "Because there is a b in both, and an n in neither." And here's mine: having one in your house is the road to insanity. (Can you tell I'm a huge Poe fan?)

You see there are a lot of possible answers for Lewis' riddle, if you think about it. And riddles help us make connections to things. And connections make us better writers. They make us reach for stronger and more interesting metaphors and similes. They help us think more deeply about things and that is the very soul of the creative process.

Let's play a game

So take some time to compare two very different, completely unrelated things. Tell how they are alike or how they are connected. Ask yourself: how is a kitten like a peach? Healthy ones are quite plump? Both are fuzzy? Both are sweet?

Look around your work area right now, and pick two things at random. How are they are same?

How is a spoon like a pencil? Here's my top-of-the-head answer: “in skilled hands, they can both produce masterpieces.”

How is a calendar like a pill bottle? How about: "if I take the contents of one, I'll live to see more of the contents of the other." Yeah, that might have been a little lame. See if you could do something better.

How are eye glasses like a cell phone? "Without one, I can't use the other." Or "they're both constantly getting misplaced."

How is a bottle of glue like a paper clip? (Okay, that one is easy.)

Check out the things on your desk. Pick any two and come up with ways they are the same or are connected. As you go through your day, try that in other rooms. This may seem silly but it'll accomplish two things. It'll make you better at connections and that makes you a better writer. And it's exercise for your brain and anything that helps keep your brain sharp is going to pay off for your writing as well.

Try it with people

You can take the connections game still further and use it to compare totally different people. You can pick people you know personally: how is your best friend like the person who annoys you most? You can pick famous people: how is Prince William like Will Smith? You can pick people from history: How is George Washington like Rosa Parks? Much like the object connections, this kind of exercise can make you think deeper about people. It can also force you to do a tiny bit of research (even if it's just to call up photos of Will Smith and Prince William). It can help you begin to look at people differently. This is especially a great exercise if the historical pair contains someone history has declared a hero and someone history has declared a villain. So how was Benito Mussolini like Winston Churchill? Again, that's likely to require some research, but if you avoid the obvious answers (both men, both balding) you will likely come away with a deeper understanding and (more importantly) some insight into how we judge people.

Being able to see how the characters you create have things in common (and things that differ) will make it easier for you to come up with situations where they clash (because conflict is the attention-grabbing gold in a story) and easier for you to make them feel real. And that makes you a better writer. And there's always the brain exercise benefit as well.

And while you're at it. What do you think? How is a raven like a writing desk?

Jan Fields is a full-time, freelance author and an Institute of Children's Literature Instructor. Would you like to have your own instructor teaching you on a one-on-one basis? Show us a sample of your work here.


Shannon Kawika Phelps
March 29, 2021

Quoth the RAVEN “nevar more” ( not even Poe- only Lewis Carroll would ever know....

March 1, 2021

I examined the similarity between the thermos and the yarn. The yarn holds electricity in itself and the thermos holds water in itself. About the similarity raven and written desk: Both do things that benefit us. The raven informs and the written desk helps to study.

January 26, 2021

Apparently Carroll's answer was: "Because it can produce a few notes, though they are very flat, and it is nevar ["raven" spelled backwards] put with the wrong end in front." Theories are that an editor thought it was a typo and changed it to "never." Source: The Annotated Alice - Definitive Edition (this one: https://www.amazon.com/Annotated-Alice-Definitive-Lewis-Carroll/dp/0393048470) - footnote on pg 72.

Thomas Robertson
December 23, 2019

Because Edgar Allan Poe wrote on both. They are both covered with black feathers, except for the writing desk.

Connie Salmon
January 20, 2018

In my writing studio, I compared my water bottle and a room thermometer. Both have a certain temperature and both can be hot or cold.

January 19, 2018

"A raven is Dark, as it is fear when I need to work at my Desk"

Roberta McLean
January 19, 2018

One has wings of fancy the other wings of flight; both can keep you up all night.

Sandra Scott
January 18, 2018

They both have long, skinny legs on which they wobble. Thanks for the brain exercise. Much needed!

Tina Jude
January 18, 2018

I like this kind of brainstorming! Thank you for this insight!

January 18, 2018

My desk is my wings that fly as I search for that which sustains me.

Joe Hopkins, Highlites ‘16
January 18, 2018

Delightful and provocative. Thank you

Janis Williams
January 18, 2018

Nevermore! Please, nevermore! (Actually, more please. MORE!!!) :D

Add Comment

Sign up for our weekly tips & market leads. 

If you write for children, sign up for our ICL newsletter.

Writing for adults? Sign up for the IFW newsletter.